Butter & Cream: I ♥ their ice cream sandwiches

That being said, don’t let the ice cream focus fool you. The people at Butter & Cream are also top notch bakers. Yes, you can buy cakes and cookies.  And, yes, they put their baked goods in some of their ice cream (like Butterscotch Brownie).  But, for me, nirvana is when they combine ice cream and cookies in their amazing ice cream sandwiches. The Salted Caramel ice cream + Brown Sugar Almond Cookie ice cream sandwich is what always keeps me coming back. One year for my birthday I got dozen of their ice cream sandwiches (assorted flavors) and stacked them up like a cake. Best. Birthday. Cake. Ever.